Talk:HISPID 5 for HISPID Users/donacc

While ABCD doesn't require abcd:PreviousSourceInstitutionID and abcd:PreviousSourceID (or abcd:PreviousUnitID for that matter) when abcd:PreviousUnit is used, I would consider that an oversight in ABCD2.06. The BioCASe provider does require these concepts to be used and I think that this is a good thing (analogous with UnitID, SourceID and SourceInstitutionID). So, I would suggest that abcd:SpecimenUnit/Acquisition/AcquiredFrom only be used when the catalogue number from the donor institution is not known and that otherwise the three above-mentioned elements of the abcd:PreviousUnit are used. –NielsKlazenga 16:35, 3 November 2012 (EST)

Better still, always use abcd://SpecimenUnit/Acquisition/AquiredFrom and, if the catalogue number from the donor institution is also known, use the PreviousUnit (all three elements) element in addition to that. So the mapping for don remains the same, while the mapping for donacc becomes: SpecimenUnit/History/PreviousUnits/PreviousUnit/PreviousSourceInstitutionID + SpecimenUnit/History/PreviousUnits/PreviousUnit/PreviousSourceID + SpecimenUnit/History/PreviousUnits/PreviousUnit/PreviousUnitID. --NielsKlazenga (talk) 15:02, 8 December 2013 (EST)